Old Worthington Area Homes for Sale

Old Worthington Area Homes for Sale

Welcome to the charming Old Worthington Area, a delightful neighborhood nestled in the heart of Worthington, Ohio. Renowned for its rich history and picturesque streets, Old Worthington offers a unique blend of small-town charm and modern conveniences. As you stroll through this enchanting community, you’ll be captivated by the historic architecture, lush tree-lined streets, and vibrant local shops and restaurants that make this area truly special.

Old Worthington is not just a place to live; it’s a lifestyle. With its close-knit community vibe, residents enjoy a variety of events throughout the year, from farmers' markets to seasonal festivals, fostering connections among neighbors and creating lasting memories. The area is also home to highly-rated schools and beautiful parks, making it an ideal location for families and individuals alike.

For those looking to call Old Worthington home, there’s an exciting array of homes for sale that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. From charming bungalows to elegant historic homes, the real estate options here reflect the area's character and appeal. Each property offers its own unique features, ensuring that you can find the perfect fit for your lifestyle.

Whether you’re seeking a cozy retreat or a spacious family home, Old Worthington’s real estate market has something for everyone. Explore the opportunities that await in this vibrant community, and discover why so many choose to call Old Worthington their home. Don’t miss your chance to be part of this remarkable neighborhood—your dream home is waiting!

Newest Old Worthington Area Homes for Sale

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cynthia C MacKenzie

Welcome home to this spacious 3BR, 2FB ranch situated on a generous half-acre lot in a prime Worthington location! A welcoming front porch sets the tone as you enter the home, which offers comfortable one-level living with hardwood floors and lots of natural light! The inviting layout features both a living room & family room, providing flexible spaces for everyday living. The dining room opens to the kitchen, creating an easy flow for meals and gatherings. Roomy bedrooms offer plenty of space for comfort, while the primary bedroom includes its own dedicated full bath. Convenient entry level laundry with sink and storage! Endless potential in the lower level for a rec room, workout room, or added storage area! Enjoy a picnic on the patio overlooking the deep yard with mature trees for added privacy! Great location near the shops and restaurants of downtown Old Worthington!

510 Evening Street, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Michael S McLaughlin

ONE-FLOOR LIVING JUST BLOCKS FROM DOWNTOWN OLD WORTHINGTON! Situated on a beautiful quarter-acre corner lot surrounded by mature landscaping, this spacious ranch offers an exceptional combination of location, updates and flexible living space. Enter through the charming morning patio into the sunny kitchen dinette, where a bay window creates the perfect spot for morning coffee and bird watching. The kitchen was remodeled in 2025 with white cabinetry, granite countertops, undermount sink, new faucet and newer stainless appliances. Refinished hardwood floors and freshly painted neutral walls flow through much of the home. The extra-large living room is filled with natural light and features a gas-log fireplace, while the four-season family room has six new vinyl windows, LVT flooring and access to the private patio. Two secondary bedrooms include the home's former primary, offering a generous closet and bay window. The renovated hall bath features quality finishes. An addition provides an expansive primary suite with full bath, walk-in closet and an adjoining office/den with built-in bookcase--also ideal as a nursery, hobby room or private retreat. First-floor laundry and an attached 2-car garage add everyday convenience. The clean basement provides abundant storage plus a room with decorative fireplace offering future rec-room possibilities. Major improvements include dual HVAC systems for zoned heating/cooling (2025), 200-amp electrical service (2019) and roof (2018). Enjoy nearby Old Worthington restaurants, coffee shops, shopping and more. Space, versatility and an outstanding Worthington location!

306 Pinney Drive, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Michael S McLaughlin ---- RE/MAX Capital Centre

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Cynthia C MacKenzie

Welcome to this stunning brand-new custom-built 3 bedroom Ranch home! Thoughtfully designed with exceptional craftsmanship, modern finishes, gorgeous white oak floors and crown molding throughout! The private primary wing is a true retreat, featuring a spacious primary bedroom, luxurious full bath, an oversized walk-in closet, and an adjoining flex room perfect for a home office or sitting area. The heart of the home is the great room, highlighted by a gorgeous tiled gas fireplace and built-ins. The dream kitchen impresses with a stylish design, abundant cabinetry, generous countertops, tile backsplash, and quality finishes. You will appreciate the Wolf gas range and double oven, the Sub-Zero french door refrigerator, and the under-counter gourmet ice machine! The adjoining dining area opens through glass doors to a large deck, making indoor-outdoor entertaining effortless. The beautifully finished lower level offers outstanding versatility, ideal as a private mother-in-law or guest suite. This amazing space includes a kitchenette, spacious family room, bedroom, and full bath! Outside, enjoy relaxing on the covered front porch, in the screened porch out back, or from the expansive deck overlooking a fully fenced backyard! Two car attached garage comes complete with a charging station and shelving organization system. This exceptional custom home combines luxury and flexible living near all the amenities of downtown Old Worthington!

6003 Weatherburn Place, Worthington

Listing Courtesy of : Cynthia C MacKenzie ---- CYMACK Real Estate

Start Your Search

Jennifer Czerwonka

Local Expertise. Global Connections. I am a Columbus native and a graduate of Upper Arlington High School and The Ohio State University. With deep roots in the community and a genuine appreciation for exceptional homes and neighborhoods, real estate has always been a natural fit. I earned my real estate license in 2010 and proudly joined Street Sotheby’s International Realty, a brand that reflects my commitment to excellence, discretion, and global reach. I provide a highly personalized, full-service real estate experience tailored to each client’s goals. Known for my attention to detail, strategic insight, and thoughtful communication, I believe luxury real estate is about far more than buying or selling a property—it is about trust, stewardship, and guiding clients through one of life’s most meaningful investments. Every home has a story, and I am committed to representing it with care and intention. As a member of Street Sotheby’s International Realty, I combine local market expertise with access to an unparalleled international network. This allows me to seamlessly assist clients with relocations, second-home purchases, and referrals both across the country and around the world. I live in Upper Arlington with my family and have a strong passion for travel, which gives me a unique perspective when working with clients seeking lifestyle-driven properties or secondary residences. From our first conversation through closing and beyond, I serve as a trusted advisor and advocate, ensuring a refined, seamless experience at every step. In today’s fast-moving and competitive market, my goal is to make the buying and selling process feel effortless, informed, and rewarding. Whether clients are upsizing, downsizing, or navigating a major transition, I provide steady guidance, discretion, and results—allowing them to move forward with confidence.

Learn More